Classical test theory ctt can arguably be described as the first formalized theory of measurement and is still the most commonly used method of describing the characteristics of assessments. Comparison of classical test theory and item response. Jul 25, 2017 classical test theory and operationalization duration. Classical test theory ctt and itemresponse theory irt classical test theory ctt and itemresponse theory irt are testing item assessment approaches. Multivariate generalizability theory was developed specifically to overcome the limitations of classical test theory in these contexts. Although different models of ctt are based on slightly different sets of assumptions, all models share a fundamental premise postulating that the observed score of a person on a test is the sum of two unobservable components, true score and. That is, qualities of outcomes, whether administered by clinicians or representing patient reports, are often describe in terms of validity and reliability, two features that are. Shifts in the assessment landscape necessitate new ways of thinking about psychometric evidence that extend beyond options available in classical test theory ctt. Classical test theory methodology and traditional reliability methods. A hypothetical data set provides examples of when the failure to use generalizability theory can lead to seriously erroneous estimates of test reliability. Classical and modern measurement theories, patient reports. A multivariate generalizability analysis of historytaking. Important characteristics of both theories are considered in this article, but primary emphasis is placed on g theory. Generalizability theory, as developed by cronbach, gleser, nanda and rajaratnam 1972, offers a more comprehensive and coherent framework than classical psychometric theory for the study of educational and psychological measurement.
Item response theory columbia university mailman school of. For further details on gt, see generalizability theory. The basic premise of all classical sociological theory is that the contemporary world is the outcome of a transition from traditional to modern societies. Classical test theory is a body of related psychometric theory that predict outcomes of psychological testing such as the difficulty of items or the ability of test takers. Generalizability theory g theory is a statistical framework for conceptualizing, investigating, and designing reliable observations. This paper discusses generalizability theory and explores its concepts using a small heuristic data set. Occasion g study of selfconcept scores occasion iii person item 1 item 2 item 3 item 1 item 2 item 3 1 425434 2 314423 3 233324. Classical test theory is an historical predecessor to g theory and, as such, it is sometimes called a parent of g theory. That book incorporated, systematized, and extended their previous research into what came to be called generalizability theory, which liberalizes classical test theory, in part through the application of analysis of variance proce dures that.
The use of generalizability g theory in the testing of. Therefore, they conducted a study using spss, sas, and matlab programs for generalizability theory analysis. The main purpose of classical test theory within psychometric testing is to recognise and develop the reliability of psychological tests and assessment. Measurement is the process of quantifying the characteristics of a person or object. Demonstrating the difference between classical test theory. The classic source on gt is the book by cronbach et al. Thus, psychological tests are tools that evaluate or measure the psychological characteristics of a subject. In chapter 7, well learn about reliability within the item response theory model. G theorys approach to estimating score reliability has important advantages over. Classical and generalizability theories of these measurement theories, item response theory has been the center of much attention among psychometricians and test specialists recently. Furthermore, the limits of classical test theory are demonstrated, and it is recommended that researchers, teachers, and psychologists instead utilize generalizability.
Generalizability theory offers an extensive conceptual framework and a powerful set of statistical procedures for characterizing and quantifying the fallibility of measurements. G theory enables an investigator to quantify and distinguish the sources of inconsistencies in observed scores that arise, or could arise, over replications of a measurement procedure. Classical test theory ctt, also known as the true score theory, refers to the analysis of test results based on test scores. Reliability and therapeutic decision through generalizability. Clinical psychologists are advised to assess clinical and statistical significance when assessing change in individual patients. Classical test theory ctt has over 80 years history, whose name coming from the comparison with modern test theory i. Classical test theory ctt has been widely used in the development, characterization, and sometimes selection of outcome measures in clinical trials. Item response theory in automated assembly of parallel test forms lin 6 jtla methods do not produce better parallelism due to factors related to the algorithm used for automated test assembly. Generalizability theory subsumes and extends classical test score theory. Generally speaking, the aim of classical test theory is to understand and improve the reliability of psychological tests.
Surveys, achievement tests, intelligence tests, psychological assessments, writing. Most training programs in education and psychology focus on classical test theory techniques for assessing score dependability. Theory of generalizability for scores and profiles lee j. The only downside is that the text is a little dated. The g theory compares with the classical test theory ctt where the focus is on.
One possible reason for such attention is the fact that item response theory has gained considerable visibility page 1 of. The conceptual foundations, assumptions, and extensions of the basic premises of ctt have allowed for the development of some excellent psychometrically sound scales. In 1972 a monograph by cronbach, gleser, nanda, and rajaratnam was published entitled the dependability of behavioral measurements. Comparing classical test theory and item response theory. Classical test theory ctt is an historical predecessor to g theory. Comparing the effectiveness of spss and edug using. To this end, we use placement exam data from one colombian university to illustrate how analyses from item response theory perspectives rasch analysis differ from, and can usefully complement classical test theory.
Classical test theory is a traditional quantitative approach to testing the reliability and validity of a scale based on its items. Generalizability theory and classical test theory eduhk moodle. Classical and generalizability theories of these measurement theories, item response theory has been the. Classical test theory and operationalization duration. One reason for the common neglect of generalizability theory is the absence of analytic facilities for this purpose in popular statistical software packages. Classical test theory is regarded as the true score theory. Comparing the effectiveness of spss and edug using different. Generalizability theory and achievement testing springerlink. Classical test theory is based on a set of assumptions regarding the properties of test scores. Although the 3rd edition was ed in 2008, there have been no revisions to the text since the 1980s. Participants were recruited from a large public midwestern university and provided complete data for the bfi on three measurement occasions n 264. Overview generalizability g theory is a statistical theory for evaluating the dependability reliability of behavioral measurements 2. With test theories, the term test or assessment is applied widely.
As this paper explores the shortcomings of classical test theory and the strengths afforded by using generalizability theory, a small heuristic data set is used to make the discussion concrete. According to classical test theory, reliability is based on the concept that every observation e. Tests for normality as mathematical support for educational measurement software article. It liberalizes classical test theory, in part through the application of analysis of variance procedures that focus on variance components.
Application of generalizability theory to the big five inventory. Broadly conceived, reliability involves quantifying the consistencies and inconsistencies in observed scores. Introduction to educational and psychological measurement using r. Abstractin this article, we illustrate how generalizability theory gtheory. Tests for normality as mathematical support for educational measurement software. Comparisons between classical test theory and item. Most investigators rely solely on classical test theory for. Classical test theory and operationalization youtube.
A comparison of classical test theory and generalizability theory illustrates how generalizability theory subsumes all other reliability estimates as special cases. Like classical test theory, gt is primarily concerned with the behavior of the test as a whole, rather than the performance of components, such as subscores or items. Applications of generalizability theory and their relations to classical test theory and structural equation modeling walter p. The present paper explains how different factors affect classical reliability estimates such as test retest, interrater, internal consistency, and equivalent forms coefficients.
Classical test theory an overview sciencedirect topics. One reason for the common neglect of generalizability theory is the absence analytic facilities for this purpose in popular statistical software packages. How do they define the consequences of such a transition on western societies. Most investigators rely solely on classical test theory for assessing reliability, whereas most experts have long recommended using generalizability theory instead. Read on to find out more about classical test theory ctt. Elements of classical reliability theory and generalizability theory. Available in the national library of australia collection. Classical test theory assumptions, equations, limitations, and item analyses c lassical test theory ctt has been the foundation for measurement theory for over 80 years. Classical test theory is an influential theory of test scores in the social sciences. It was originally introduced by lee cronbach and his colleagues.
Practical applications of generalizability theory for designing. A multivariate generalizability analysis of historytaking a. This isnt a big problem on the classical test theory chapters, but more modern chapters such as the item response theory chapter need updating. Classical test theory ctt is a measurement theory used primarily in psychology, education, and related fields. Morris, and murat kilinc university of iowa abstract although widely recognized as a comprehensive framework for representing score reliability, generalizability theory g theory, despite its. The identification and reduction of measurement errors is a major challenge in psychological testing. The in generalizability theory is analogous to the. For example, when the number of the irtbased constraints e. In addition, the two theories are briefly compared with item response theory. The focus of classical test theory ctt is on determining error of the measurement. In psychometrics, the theory has been superseded by the more sophisticated models in item response theory irt and generalizability theory g theory. I would like to thank richard shavelson for his helpful comments on an earlier draft of this chapter. Theories of measurement help to explain measurement results i. Generalizability theory g theory provides a flexible, multifaceted approach to estimating score reliability.
The advantage of g theory lies in the fact that researchers can estimate what proportion of the total variance in the results is due to the individual factors that often vary in assessment, such as setting, time, items, and raters. All other potential sources of variation existing in the testing materials such as. In this study, the classical test theory and generalizability theory were used for determination to reliability of scores obtained from measurement tool of mathematics success. Applications of generalizability theory and their relations to. Estimate different forms of reliability using statistical software, and interpret the. The use of generalizability g theory in the testing of linguistic minorities guillermo solanoflores, university of colorado, boulder, and min li, university of washington, seattle we contend that generalizability g theory allows the design of psychometric approaches to testing englishlanguage learners.
Section 2 briefly sketches foundations of classical test theory see the chapter by lewis for a thorough development of the theory and focuses on traditional methods of estimating reliability. This paper provides an applied example illustrating the complimentary relationship among classical measurement theory, item response theory, and generalizability theory when each are used in the process of scale. This article presents an overview of classical test theory and g theory focusing on application, including analysis, emphasizing advantages of g theory over traditional reliability measures for anal ysis of observergenerated performance data. Relatedly, generalizability theory was used to test the dependability of the clinical cutting scores developed in previous studies. Influences on and limitations of classical test theory. A comparison of the approaches of generalizability theory and item response theory in estimating the reliability of test scores for testletcomposed tests lee, guemin. Classical test theory is rarely considered by individuals taking psychometric tests or the companies using them, but is essential in its uses, as there is no point in a test that has to be highly scrutinized for errors before the candidates responses are even measured. The techniques of ctt are applied in assessment situations to improve test analysis and. Why generalizability theory is essential and classical. The statistics produced under ctt include measures of item difficulty. In the context of pro measures, classical test theory assumes that each observed score x on a pro instrument is a combination of an underlying true score t on the concept of interest and unsystematic i. Classical test theory vs item response theory by chris. Spss and sas programs for generalizability theory analyses.
Overview of classical test theory and item response theory. Generalizability theory and classical test theory researchgate. Generalizability theory acknowledges and allows for variability in assessment conditions that may affect measurements. In psychology, tests are either psychological or psychotechnical and are designed to study or evaluate a function. The purpose of the present study was to examine the big five personality inventory score reliability bfi. May 31, 2015 classical test theory ctt and itemresponse theory irt classical test theory ctt and itemresponse theory irt are testing item assessment approaches. A comparison of classical test theory and generalizability theory will illustrate how generalizability theory subsumes all ether reliability estimates as special cases. Generalizability theory and classical test theory, applied measurement in education, 24 2011, pp. Classical versus generalizability theory of measurement.
The use of generalizability g theory in the testing of linguistic minorities guillermo solanoflores, university of colorado, boulder, and min li, university of washington, seattle we contend that generalizability g theory allows the design of. Application of generalizability theory to the big five. Introduction to g theory are provided by brennan 1977, 1979, 1983, brennan, jajoura, and beaton 1981, brennan and kane 1979, cardinet and toourneur 1978, cronbach et al. Comparisons between classical test theory and item response. In theory of measurement in education and psychology, classical test theory ctt is a popular framework. The application of the gtheory or classical test theory, ctt only makes. G theory pinpoints the sources of measurement error, disentangles them, and estimates each one. Summary of classical sociological theory decolonize all. For the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. The theory starts from the assumption that systematic effects between responses of examinees are due only to variation in ability of interest. Technically, classical, generalizability, and item response theory are not. The use of classical measurement theory, item response theory.
27 927 748 1524 259 486 27 428 460 1323 323 1634 549 265 221 563 1406 464 250 236 1603 699 439 549 1474 490 984 570 90 1212 173 992 1118 190 1338 701 621 589 645